Homepage > Blank Review Commercial Appraisal Template
Article Structure

The Review Commercial Appraisal form serves as a critical tool for evaluating the accuracy and reliability of appraisal reports. This comprehensive document captures essential details about the property in question, including its location, type, and the appraiser's contact information. It outlines the purpose of the appraisal, specifying the value sought—be it market value or another type—and provides a framework for assessing various interests valued, such as fee simple or leased interest. The form also addresses property identification, ownership, and assessment, ensuring that all relevant data, like legal descriptions and tax information, are thoroughly reviewed. A significant portion of the form focuses on location analysis, examining regional trends and potential hazards that could affect property value. Additionally, it includes sections dedicated to property descriptions, highest and best use evaluations, and valuation methods, such as the cost approach and income capitalization approach. By systematically guiding reviewers through each aspect of the appraisal, this form ensures a thorough and fair assessment, ultimately contributing to informed decision-making in commercial real estate transactions.

Form Sample

COMMERCIAL APPRAISAL REVIEW FORM

The appraisal report which is the subject of this review is briefly identified and described as follows:

Name of Project/Property __________________________________________________________________________________________

Location/Legal __________________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of propert ____________________________________________________________________ ❐ Existing ❐ Proposed Construction

Name of Appraiser _________________________________________________________________ Telephone ____________________

Address

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Report Addressed to: _______________________________________________________________ Telephone ____________________

Address

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of Appraisal Report: ❐ Narrative ❐ Printed Form ❐ Other (identify) ___________________________________________________

Section I — Purpose and Function of Appraisal

Value Sought:

❐ Market Value

❐ Other (identify)

Date of value:

❐ Current

❐ Future

❐ Past

 

 

______________

Definitions Given For:

❐ Value Sought

❐ Interest To Be Valued

Interests Valued:

❐ Fee Simple

❐ Leased Interest

 

❐ Market Rent

❐ Other (identify)

 

❐ Easements

❐ Other (identify)

 

 

__________________

 

 

______________

Assumptions and

❐ Standard

❐ Consistent with

Real Estate Valued

❐ Land

❐ Improvements

Limiting Conditions:

 

Valuation Process

 

❐ Ground Lease

❐ Personal Property

 

❐ Third Party

❐ Unreasonable or

 

❐ Other (identify)_______________

 

Report

Excessive

 

Comments:

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section II — Property Identification, Ownership and Assessment

Does the report adequately contain or identify:

Yes

No

N/A

 

 

Yes

No N/A

 

Property Location/Address:

Owners of Record

 

Legal Description

History of Ownership

 

 

 

 

Real Estate Tax Information

If Applicable to Subject Property:

 

 

 

 

Assessments, Bonds, etc.

Amount of Purchase Price

$____________

Existence of:

 

 

 

Pending Sales Price

$____________

Deed Restrictions

Asking Price

$____________

Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions

Option Price

$____________

Moratoriums

Other

$____________

Comments:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section III — Location Analysis

Does the report adequately describe or identify:

Does report:

 

Region

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Sum up and rate the above area

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

City

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Identify and discuss important trends

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Neighborhood

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Identify nuisances or hazards

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section IV — Property Description

Comment upon the descriptions and analysis of the following:

IMPROVEMENTS:

 

SITE:

 

Adequate description of physical features ❐ Yes ❐ No

Adequate description of physical features❐ Yes ❐ No

Attention given to:

 

Identification of encumbrances

❐Yes ❐ No

Quality

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does the report state adequacy of site for

 

Functional Utility and Appeal

❐ Yes ❐ No

existing or proposed use

❐Yes ❐ No

Age

❐ Yes ❐ No

Utilities available

❐Yes ❐ No

Condition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Special Problems:

 

Hazardous Conditions

❐ Yes ❐ No

Flood

❐Yes ❐ No

ZONING:

 

Environmental Hazards, Seismic, Toxic etc.

Statement

❐ Yes ❐ No

Other (identify)_________________

❐Yes ❐ No

Definition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section V — Highest and Best Use

Definition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does property conform to zoning and

 

Components

❐ Yes ❐ No

neighborhood

❐ Yes ❐ No

Conclusion of Highest and Best Use______________________

Is use legal and physically possible

❐ Yes ❐ No

Current zoning ______________________________________

Has the report in this or other sections discussed:

Status zoning change _________________________________

Marketability (supply-demand, market trends,

Status of building permit (if possible construction) ____________

absorption occupancy levels)

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does report discuss feasibility/profitability

❐ Yes ❐ No

Other (identify) ____________________________________

 

 

Were other studies/reports considered

❐ Yes ❐No

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Copyright © by the National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriters 1224 North Nokomis NE, Alexandria, Minnesota,USA. This formReview Form No. 4002 may be reproduced without written consent, however, the “National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriter’s must be acknowledged and credited.

SECTION VI — Property Valuation

Comment and rate the approaches to value:

 

 

 

 

COST APPROACH:

Satisfactory

Unsatisfactory

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW ANALYSIS (DCF)

 

Format

 

 

Satisfactory

Unsatisfactory

Adequacy of data

 

Format

Source of costs

 

Adequacy of data and support for:

 

Land value estimate

 

Holding Period

Estimated cost new

 

Growth Rates

Depreciation estimate

 

Discount Rate

SALES COMPARISON APPROACH:

 

Development of Cash Flow Estimates ❐

Format

 

Reversionary Value

Adequacy of data

 

Other Methods of Processing Income

 

Sources of data

 

Stream (Mortgage Equity, Band of

 

Summary of sales table

 

Investments, etc.)

Use of adjustment grid table

RECONCILIATION:

 

 

Comparative analysis of sales

Indicated values are:

 

 

INCOME CAPITALIZATION APPROACH:

 

Cost Approach

$ __________

 

Format

 

Sales Comparison Approach

$ __________

 

Selection of proper capitalization

 

Income Approach

$ __________

 

method

 

DCF Analysis

$ __________

 

Adequacy of data and support for:

 

 

Other (Pending Sale, etc.)

 

 

Comparable Rentals

 

Value Conclusion

 

$ ________

Vacancy and Loss Factor

 

Allocation as Follows:

 

 

Operating History

 

Land

$ __________

 

Rent Roll

 

Improvements

$ __________

 

Income Estimate

 

Personal Property

$ __________

 

Expense Estimate

 

Other

$ __________

 

Net Operating Income

 

Total Value

 

$ ________

Capitalization Rate

 

 

 

 

Comments:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section VII — Other Report Requirements

Does the report contain a certification ❐ Yes

❐ No

Does the principal appraiser make

 

 

Is the report co-signed

❐ Yes

❐ No

statement of concurrence with value

 

 

Did the principal appraiser sign the

 

conclusion

❐ Yes

❐ No

report

❐ Yes

❐ No

Does the report contain appraiser(s)

 

 

Did the principal appraiser personally

 

qualifications

❐ Yes

❐ No

inspect subject property

❐ Yes

❐ No

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Section VIII — Final Rating of Appraisal

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Acceptable

Unacceptable

 

Acceptable

Unacceptable

Report Format

 

 

Property Valuation:

 

 

Readability and neatness

Feasibility/Profitability

Mathematical accuracy

Market Trends

Exhibits (Photos, Maps, etc.)

Cost Approach

Appraiser’s analytical ability

Sales Comparison Approach

Purpose and function of appraisal ❐

Income Approach

Property identification

DCF

Locational analysis

Reconciliation

Property Description

Date of Appraisal

Site

Overall Rating of Appraisal

 

 

Improvements

 

 

 

Highest and Best Use

 

 

 

Brief Comments on Unacceptable Ratings:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section IX — Reviewer’s Conclusions — Recommendations

Scope of Review:

 

 

If reviewer does not concur with the soundness if conclusion, then

Read report

❐ Yes

❐ No

what is the recommended action:

Interviewed appraiser

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Totally reject appraisal

Field Review

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Have appraiser rework, revise, update the appraisal

Does the Reviewer concur with

 

 

❐ Have another appraisal prepared by someone else

the soundness of conclusion:

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Other

Concluding Comments:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Reviewer’s Signature _____________________________________________________________________________________________

Name of Reviewer __________________________________________________________________ Date ________________________

Position ___________________________________________________________________________ Department __________________

Address __________________________________________________________________________ Telephone ___________________

City, State, Zip __________________________________________________________________________________________________

Copyright © by the National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriters P.O. Box 879, Palm Springs, California, 92263 USA. This form

Review Form No. 4002

may be reproduced without written consent, however, the “National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriter’s must be acknowledged and credited.

 

Document Specifications

Fact Name Description
Purpose of the Form The Review Commercial Appraisal form serves to evaluate the accuracy and reliability of an appraisal report for commercial properties, ensuring that the valuation meets industry standards.
Types of Properties The form accommodates various property types, including existing structures and proposed constructions, allowing flexibility in appraisal reviews.
Valuation Methods It includes multiple approaches to value, such as the Cost Approach, Sales Comparison Approach, and Income Capitalization Approach, offering a comprehensive evaluation framework.
Ownership and Assessment The form requires detailed information about property ownership, legal descriptions, and tax assessments, which are critical for accurate appraisal reviews.
Location Analysis Section III emphasizes the importance of location by requiring an analysis of regional trends, neighborhood characteristics, and potential nuisances affecting property value.
Governing Laws In many states, appraisal reviews are governed by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), ensuring that appraisals adhere to nationally recognized standards.

Steps to Filling Out Review Commercial Appraisal

After completing the Review Commercial Appraisal form, the next steps involve submitting it to the appropriate parties for further review or action. Ensure that all sections are filled out accurately to provide a comprehensive overview of the appraisal.

  1. Begin by filling in the Name of Project/Property and Location/Legal sections at the top of the form.
  2. Indicate the Type of Property by checking either Existing or Proposed Construction.
  3. Provide the Name of Appraiser, Telephone, and Address of the appraiser.
  4. Fill in the Report Addressed to section with the recipient's name, telephone number, and address.
  5. Choose the Type of Appraisal Report by checking one of the options: Narrative, Printed Form, or Other.
  6. In Section I, indicate the Value Sought and the Date of Value. Mark any relevant Definitions Given For and Interests Valued.
  7. Provide details regarding any Assumptions and Limiting Conditions and include any Excessive Comments in the designated area.
  8. In Section II, answer the questions regarding Property Identification, Ownership, and Assessment with Yes, No, or N/A.
  9. Proceed to Section III to analyze the Location and provide comments.
  10. In Section IV, comment on the descriptions of Improvements and Site features.
  11. Complete Section V by discussing the Highest and Best Use and answering any related questions.
  12. In Section VI, comment on the Property Valuation approaches and rate each method used.
  13. Check off the requirements in Section VII regarding report certifications and appraiser qualifications.
  14. Provide an overall rating in Section VIII and include any comments on unacceptable ratings.
  15. Finally, complete Section IX with the Reviewer’s Conclusions and sign the form.

More About Review Commercial Appraisal

What is the purpose of the Review Commercial Appraisal form?

The Review Commercial Appraisal form is designed to assess the quality and accuracy of a commercial appraisal report. It helps reviewers evaluate various aspects of the appraisal, including property identification, valuation methods, and compliance with standards. This ensures that the appraisal meets the necessary criteria for decision-making.

What information is required about the property on the form?

Key details about the property must be provided, such as the name, location, and type of property (existing or proposed construction). The appraiser's contact information and the type of appraisal report (narrative, printed form, etc.) are also necessary. This information helps in identifying the specific appraisal being reviewed.

What types of value can be sought in the appraisal?

The form allows for the identification of different types of value sought, including market value and other specified values. Reviewers can assess whether the appraisal aligns with the intended purpose, such as determining market rent or fee simple interest.

How does the form evaluate the location analysis of the property?

The location analysis section assesses whether the report adequately describes the property's region, city, and neighborhood. Reviewers check for important trends, nuisances, and hazards that may affect the property's value. This analysis provides context for the appraisal's conclusions.

What are the key components of the highest and best use analysis?

This section examines whether the property conforms to zoning regulations and if the proposed use is legal and physically possible. It also considers marketability and feasibility. Reviewers look for discussions regarding supply and demand, market trends, and any other relevant studies.

What valuation approaches are included in the review?

The form covers several valuation approaches, including cost approach, sales comparison approach, and income capitalization approach. Reviewers evaluate the adequacy of data, format, and support for each method, ensuring that the valuation is robust and well-supported.

How does the form assess the report's overall quality?

Reviewers rate the report's format, readability, mathematical accuracy, and overall presentation. They also evaluate the appraiser's analytical ability and the effectiveness of the valuation methods used. This comprehensive assessment helps determine whether the appraisal meets industry standards.

What actions can be taken if the reviewer does not concur with the appraisal conclusion?

If the reviewer disagrees with the appraisal's soundness, they can recommend various actions. These may include rejecting the appraisal, asking the appraiser to revise it, or obtaining a new appraisal from another professional. This ensures that the final appraisal is reliable and accurate.

How does the form ensure compliance with appraisal standards?

The Review Commercial Appraisal form includes sections that require the reviewer to verify whether the appraisal contains necessary certifications, qualifications, and inspections. By checking these elements, the form helps ensure that the appraisal complies with industry standards and regulations.

What should be included in the reviewer’s final comments?

Final comments should summarize the reviewer's findings and provide any additional recommendations. This section allows the reviewer to express their thoughts on the appraisal's strengths and weaknesses, offering a clear conclusion on its overall quality and reliability.

Common mistakes

  1. Incomplete Property Identification: Failing to provide a complete and accurate property location, legal description, and ownership details can lead to significant issues. Ensure all sections are filled out thoroughly to avoid confusion.

  2. Neglecting to Specify Value Type: It's crucial to clearly indicate the value sought, whether it is market value or another type. Missing this information can render the appraisal less useful.

  3. Inadequate Comments on Assumptions: Not providing sufficient comments regarding assumptions and limiting conditions can hinder the review process. Always include detailed explanations to support your analysis.

  4. Failure to Rate Approaches to Value: Omitting ratings for various valuation approaches may leave gaps in the review. Each method should be assessed to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of the appraisal report.

Documents used along the form

When conducting a review of a commercial appraisal, several additional forms and documents may be required to ensure a comprehensive evaluation. Each of these documents serves a specific purpose in the appraisal process, providing essential information and context. Below is a list of common forms and documents that are often used alongside the Review Commercial Appraisal form.

  • Appraisal Report: This document contains the appraiser's analysis and conclusion regarding the value of the property. It includes details about the property, the methodology used, and the final valuation.
  • Market Analysis Report: This report provides insights into the current market conditions affecting the property. It may include data on comparable sales, trends, and economic indicators that influence property values.
  • Property Condition Report: This document outlines the physical condition of the property, including any repairs needed or potential issues that could affect its value.
  • Zoning Compliance Letter: A letter from the local zoning authority confirming that the property complies with local zoning regulations. This is crucial for determining the property's highest and best use.
  • Environmental Assessment: This report evaluates potential environmental hazards associated with the property. It assesses risks such as contamination or other environmental concerns that could impact value.
  • Lease Agreements: If the property is leased, copies of lease agreements provide vital information about rental income, tenant responsibilities, and lease terms, all of which can influence valuation.
  • Tax Assessment Records: These records provide information on the assessed value of the property for tax purposes, which can serve as a benchmark for the appraisal process.
  • Sales Comparison Analysis: This document compares the subject property to similar properties that have recently sold. It helps to support the appraiser's conclusions regarding market value.

Utilizing these documents alongside the Review Commercial Appraisal form can enhance the accuracy and reliability of the appraisal review process. Each form contributes unique insights, ensuring that all aspects of the property and its market environment are thoroughly considered.

Similar forms

The Review Commercial Appraisal form shares similarities with the Property Appraisal Report. Both documents assess the value of real estate properties, providing detailed descriptions and analyses. They include information about property location, ownership, and characteristics. Additionally, both forms aim to establish a fair market value based on comparable sales and other valuation methods. The Property Appraisal Report often serves as the foundation for the review process, ensuring that the appraisal meets industry standards and guidelines.

Another similar document is the Market Analysis Report. This report focuses on the trends and conditions of the real estate market surrounding a specific property. Like the Review Commercial Appraisal form, it evaluates factors such as supply and demand, pricing trends, and neighborhood characteristics. Both documents aim to provide insights that help in determining a property’s market value and potential for investment. The Market Analysis Report often complements the appraisal review by offering a broader perspective on market dynamics.

The Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) is also comparable to the Review Commercial Appraisal form. A CMA evaluates similar properties in the area to estimate a property's value. This document typically includes recent sales data, active listings, and market trends. Both the CMA and the Review Commercial Appraisal form utilize comparable sales to support their findings. They both aim to provide a comprehensive view of a property's value within its market context.

The Appraisal Review Report aligns closely with the Review Commercial Appraisal form as well. This report specifically critiques and evaluates the findings of an appraisal. It assesses whether the original appraisal meets professional standards and guidelines. Both documents focus on the appraisal process and seek to ensure accuracy and reliability in property valuation. The Appraisal Review Report often serves as a quality control measure for the appraisal process.

The Residential Appraisal Report is another document that bears similarities. While it focuses on residential properties, its structure and purpose align with the Review Commercial Appraisal form. Both documents provide detailed property descriptions, valuation methods, and market data. They aim to establish an accurate value for the property based on various factors, including location and condition. The Residential Appraisal Report, like the Review Commercial Appraisal form, is essential for lenders and buyers in making informed decisions.

The Commercial Lease Analysis is also relevant. This document examines the terms and conditions of commercial leases, focusing on their impact on property value. Similar to the Review Commercial Appraisal form, it assesses market conditions and financial considerations. Both documents provide insights that help stakeholders understand the financial implications of property ownership or leasing. They serve as tools for evaluating the economic viability of real estate investments.

The Property Condition Report is another document that shares commonalities. This report focuses on the physical state of a property, detailing any issues or necessary repairs. While the Review Commercial Appraisal form emphasizes value, the Property Condition Report informs about the condition of the property. Both documents are crucial in the decision-making process, helping buyers and investors understand potential risks and costs associated with a property.

The Feasibility Study is similar in that it evaluates the potential success of a real estate project. This document examines various factors, such as market demand, financial projections, and site conditions. Like the Review Commercial Appraisal form, it aims to provide a thorough analysis that supports investment decisions. Both documents help stakeholders assess whether a project is viable and worth pursuing.

Finally, the Investment Analysis Report aligns with the Review Commercial Appraisal form. This report evaluates the potential return on investment for a property. It considers factors such as cash flow, expenses, and market conditions. Both documents aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of a property's financial performance and value. They help investors make informed decisions based on thorough analysis and research.

Dos and Don'ts

When filling out the Review Commercial Appraisal form, it's crucial to approach the task with care. Here are four important dos and don'ts to keep in mind:

  • Do provide complete and accurate information in every section. This ensures clarity and helps avoid delays in processing.
  • Do double-check all numerical entries, especially financial figures. Mistakes can lead to significant misunderstandings.
  • Don't leave any required fields blank. Incomplete submissions may be returned for additional information.
  • Don't use vague language in your comments. Be specific and clear to facilitate a thorough review.

By following these guidelines, you can help ensure that your review is processed smoothly and efficiently.

Misconceptions

  • Misconception 1: The Review Commercial Appraisal form is only for existing properties.
  • This is not true. The form can also be used for proposed construction projects, allowing appraisers to evaluate potential values before the property is built.

  • Misconception 2: The form does not require detailed property descriptions.
  • In fact, the form emphasizes the need for comprehensive descriptions, including physical features, zoning, and any encumbrances that may affect the property.

  • Misconception 3: The appraisal review process is merely a formality.
  • On the contrary, the review process plays a crucial role in ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the appraisal, addressing any potential discrepancies or concerns.

  • Misconception 4: All appraisals are valued the same way.
  • Different approaches to value exist, such as the cost approach, sales comparison approach, and income capitalization approach. Each method serves a unique purpose and is selected based on the property type and market conditions.

  • Misconception 5: The reviewer has no authority to challenge the appraiser’s conclusions.
  • Reviewers are empowered to question the appraiser’s findings. If they disagree with the conclusions, they can recommend further action, including revisions or obtaining a new appraisal.

  • Misconception 6: The form is only relevant for commercial properties.
  • While it is designed for commercial appraisals, the principles and processes can also be applied to mixed-use or residential properties, depending on the context.

  • Misconception 7: The form does not account for market trends.
  • In reality, the form includes sections specifically dedicated to analyzing market conditions, trends, and their impact on property valuation.

  • Misconception 8: A single reviewer can assess the entire appraisal effectively.
  • Multiple perspectives are often beneficial. Engaging different reviewers can provide a more comprehensive evaluation of the appraisal's soundness and accuracy.

  • Misconception 9: The Review Commercial Appraisal form is static and does not evolve.
  • On the contrary, the form can be updated and modified to reflect changes in industry standards, regulations, and best practices, ensuring it remains relevant and effective.

Key takeaways

Filling out and using the Review Commercial Appraisal form can be straightforward if you keep a few key points in mind. Here are some important takeaways:

  • Clearly Identify the Property: Begin by providing a detailed description of the project or property, including its location, type, and ownership details.
  • Understand the Purpose: Determine the value sought, whether it’s market value or another type, and specify the date of value.
  • Review Property Details: Ensure that the report includes essential information like the legal description, history of ownership, and any existing encumbrances.
  • Analyze Location: Assess the adequacy of the location analysis. It should identify trends, nuisances, and hazards that may affect property value.
  • Evaluate Improvements: The report should describe the physical features of the property, including its age, condition, and any special problems that may exist.
  • Consider Highest and Best Use: Confirm that the report discusses the legal and physical possibilities for the property, as well as its marketability.
  • Examine Valuation Methods: Review the different approaches to value, such as the cost approach and income capitalization approach, ensuring they are well-supported by data.
  • Final Review and Recommendations: After completing the review, provide clear conclusions and recommendations regarding the appraisal’s soundness and any necessary actions.

By keeping these takeaways in mind, you can ensure a thorough and effective review of the commercial appraisal report.